top of page

How to Choose a Professional Book Editor for Your Self-Published Book

Key Criteria to Consider

blog post image for article about how to choose a professional book editor in 10 steps

You've poured your soul into your manuscript, but now you need the right editor to take it to the next level. Choosing a professional book editor feels like navigating a maze. Today, we're diving into the secrets of finding the perfect match. From experience to budget, we'll cover all you need to know. Let's unravel the mystery of choosing a pro editor.


How to choose a professional book editor

» Experience and expertise

Look for an editor who specializes in your genre or type of book. Experience in editing similar works will ensure they understand the conventions, style, and audience expectations specific to your book.

» Portfolio and samples

Review the editor's portfolio and ask for samples of their previous work. This will give you insight into their editing style, attention to detail, and the quality of their revisions.

» Credentials and qualifications

Check the editor's credentials and qualifications. A degree in English, literature, or a related field, along with professional editing certifications or memberships in editing associations, can indicate their proficiency and dedication to their craft.

» Communication and compatibility

Effective communication is crucial in the editing process. Choose an editor with whom you feel comfortable communicating openly and who is responsive to your questions, concerns, and feedback.

» Editing process and services offered

Understand the editor's process and the specific services they offer. Do they provide developmental editing, copyediting, or proofreading? Clarify what level of editing your book requires and ensure the editor can meet those needs.

» Rates and budget

While cost shouldn't be the sole determining factor, it's essential to consider your budget. Request quotes from multiple editors and compare their rates against the quality of their services and their fit with your project.

» Reviews and recommendations

Seek out reviews and testimonials from previous clients. Recommendations from other authors or self-publishers can provide valuable insights into the editor's reliability, professionalism, and the results they deliver.

Additionally, inquire about how the editor handles challenges such as writer's block and their strategies on how to overcome writer's block, as their approach to supporting authors through creative hurdles can be an important factor in your decision.

» Timeline and availability

Determine the editor's availability and turnaround time for your project. Ensure their schedule aligns with your timeline and that they can accommodate any deadlines you may have.

» Contract and terms

Before finalizing your decision, review the editor's contract or terms of service carefully. Pay attention to factors such as payment terms, revision policies, confidentiality agreements, and copyright ownership.

» Gut feeling

Trust your instincts. Choose an editor whose vision aligns with yours and who demonstrates genuine enthusiasm for your project. A positive working relationship can make the editing process more enjoyable and ultimately lead to a better end result.


Now that you've discovered the key criteria for choosing a professional book editor, we'd love to hear from you!

Have you worked with an editor before? What factors do you consider most important when selecting an editor for your project?

Share your experiences and insights in the comments below. Let's start a conversation and help each other on our self-publishing journeys!



Never miss updates.

Read about art, new books, author interviews, and self-publishing tips.


Read More in the Book Club

bottom of page